Buy the ARP T-Shirt! BIOS Optimization Guide Money Savers!
 

 18 April 2014
 N/A
  N/A
 Storage
 Dr. Adrian Wong
 2.0
 Discuss here !
 39162
 
   
Desktop Graphics Card Comparison Guide Rev. 33.0
Covering 628 desktop graphics cards, this comprehensive comparison allows you ... Read here
BIOS Option Of The Week - Virtualization Technology
Since 1999, we have been developing the BIOS Optimization Guide, affectionately known... Read here
   
Buy The BOG Book Subscribe To The BOG! Latest Money Savers!
Western Digital Black² (WD1001X06XDTL) Dual Drive Review Rev. 2.0
Digg! Reddit!Add to Reddit | Bookmark this article:

IO Meter (SSD)

We compared the SSD component of the WD Black² (WD1001X06XDTL) to the industry standards - the Intel 520 Series SSD and the Intel X25-M G2. If you wish to see how the WD Black² compares to other solid state drives, take a look at our Solid State Drive Performance Comparison Guide, which we will be updating shortly.

 

Throughput (Random Access)

Although the IMFT 60074157 flash memory is capable of delivering a peak read speed of 390 MB/s, the Western Digital Black²'s SSD was only capable of delivering a random read speed of just over 322 MB/s, with a far poorer random write speed of 147 MB/s. This puts it closer to the Intel X25-M G2 in performance, than the newer Intel 520 Series SSD.

While reads are always faster than writes in solid state drives, the results for the smaller accesses may flip if the solid state drive uses a write combine buffer. The small writes appear much faster because they are being accumulated in the write combine buffer (which is usually fast DDR3 SDRAM memory) before being written to the drive itself.

Test

     WD Black²    

Intel 520 Series

Intel X25-M G2

Difference
(vs. Intel 520)

512 KB Read

322.52 MB/s

369.16 MB/s

195.49 MB/s

- 12.6%

512 KB Write

146.98 MB/s

234.78 MB/s

102.66 MB/s

- 37.4%

4 KB Read

24.90 MB/s

55.12 MB/s

21.36 MB/s

- 54.8%

4 KB Write

50.94 MB/s

73.07 MB/s

53.95 MB/s

- 30.3%

 

Random Access Time

Test

    WD Black²    

Intel 520 Series

Intel X25-M G2

Difference
(vs. Intel 520)

512 KB Read

1.63 ms

1.42 ms

2.68 ms

+ 14.5%

512 KB Write

3.57 ms

2.24 ms

5.11 ms

+ 59.5%

4 KB Read

0.16 ms

0.09 ms

0.19 ms

+ 92.8%

4 KB Write

0.08 ms

0.06 ms

0.08 ms

+ 32.9%

 

CPU Utilization (Random Access)

Test

    WD Black²     

Intel 520 Series

Intel X25-M G2

Difference
(vs. Intel 520)

512 KB Read

1.76%

0.72%

0.50%

+ 145.5%

512 KB Write

0.99%

0.70%

0.40%

+ 41.7%

4 KB Read

3.60%

4.99%

5.98%

- 28.0%

4 KB Write

8.96%

6.86%

2.25%

+ 30.6%

 

 

Throughput (Sequential Access)

Even in the sequential test, the Western Digital Black²'s SSD was significantly slower than the Intel 520 Series SSD. As fast as the IMFT flash memory is, the JMicron JMF667H, which is a quad-channel controller, just cannot catch up with better SSD controllers that have far greater parallelism. The SandForce SF-2281 controller used in the Intel 520 Series SSD, for example, has 8 channels.

Do note the particularly poor small sequential read and write speeds. The WD Black²'s SSD actually performs poorer in these aspects than the Intel X25-M G2.

Test

    WD Black²    

Intel 520 Series

Intel X25-M G2

Difference
(vs. Intel 520)

512 KB Read

325.48 MB/s

371.44 MB/s

262.83 MB/s

- 12.4%

512 KB Write

147.03 MB/s

234.33 MB/s

103.32 MB/s

- 37.3%

4 KB Read

37.72 MB/s

65.13 MB/s

71.28 MB/s

- 42.1%

4 KB Write

51.72 MB/s

72.11 MB/s

57.58 MB/s

- 28.3%

 

Sequential Access Time

Test

    WD Black²    

Intel 520 Series

Intel X25-M G2

Difference
(vs. Intel 520)

512 KB Read

1.63 ms

1.41 ms

2.00 ms

+ 15.5%

512 KB Write

3.57 ms

2.24 ms

5.08 ms

+ 59.2%

4 KB Read

0.11 ms

0.07 ms

0.06 ms

+ 65.5%

4 KB Write

0.08 ms

0.06 ms

0.39 ms

+ 31.0%

 

CPU Utilization (Sequential Access)

Test

    WD Black²    

Intel 520 Series

Intel X25-M G2

Difference
(vs. Intel 520)

512 KB Read

1.65%

0.76%

0.79%

+ 117.1%

512 KB Write

1.16%

0.55%

0.51%

+ 111.9%

4 KB Read

6.07%

5.59%

6.67%

+ 8.7%

4 KB Write

8.68%

6.97%

5.56%

+ 24.6%

 

Support Tech ARP!

If you like our work, you can help support out work by visiting our sponsors, participate in the Tech ARP Forums, or even donate to our fund. Any help you can render is greatly appreciated!

Page

Topic

1

Western Digital Black² Overview

2

Introduction, Specifications, Packaging

3

The Western Digital Black² Dual Drive
Advanced Format Technology
Installing The Drive, Maintenance

4

Peeking Under The PCB, SSD Controller
Flash Memory & Write Combine Buffer

5

Testing The Black², Usable Capacities
Max. Temperature, Transfer Rate Profiles

6

Transfer Rate Range
WinBench 99 Test Results

7

IO Meter (SSD) Test Results

8

IO Meter (HDD) Test Results

9

IOPS Scaling (SSD) Results

10

AS SSD Benchmark (SSD) Results

11

ATTO Disk Benchmark (SSD) Results

12

Conclusion, Award, Lowest Prices

Support us by buying from Amazon.com!

Grab a FREE 30-day trial of Amazon Prime for free shipping, instant access to 40,000 movies and TV episodes and the Kindle Owners' Lending Library!


 
   
The Samsung Galaxy A8 Launch Report
Western Digital Black² (WD1001X06XDTL) Dual Drive Review Rev. 2.0
Western Digital AV-GP 2 TB Hard Disk Drive Review
Intel 45nm Core 2 Mobile Processor Pre-Launch Update
NVIDIA Buys Over AGEIA
The Task Killer In Windows XP
OCZ PC-3200 Gold Voltage eXtreme Dual Channel DDR Memory Review
LITE-ON SOHW-1693S Dual Layer DVD±R Writer Pictorial Review
AC Ryan XTOR Tanky Hard Disk Cooler Overview
Futuremark's Approved NVIDIA Drivers For 3DMark03

 


Copyright © Tech ARP.com. All rights reserved.