Buy the ARP T-Shirt! BIOS Optimization Guide Money Savers!
 

 30 July 2012
 N/A
  N/A
 Storage
 Dr. Adrian Wong
 1.0
 Discuss here !
 49416
 
   
Desktop Graphics Card Comparison Guide Rev. 33.0
Covering 628 desktop graphics cards, this comprehensive comparison allows you ... Read here
BIOS Option Of The Week - Virtualization Technology
Since 1999, we have been developing the BIOS Optimization Guide, affectionately known... Read here
   
Buy The BOG Book Subscribe To The BOG! Latest Money Savers!
Western Digital VelociRaptor (WD1000DHTZ) 1 TB Hard Disk Drive Review
Digg! Reddit!Add to Reddit | Bookmark this article:

IO Meter

We compared the new 1 TB Western Digital VelociRaptor to the 600 GB VelociRaptor and the 300 GB VelociRaptor so you can see the difference between this new VelociRaptor, and its predecessors.

If you wish to see how the 1 TB VelociRaptor compares to other hard disk drives, take a look at our Hard Disk Drive Performance Comparison Guide.

 

Throughput (Random Access)

Test

VelociRaptor
1 TB

VelociRaptor
600 GB

VelociRaptor
300 GB

Difference
(vs. 600 GB)

Difference
(vs. 300 GB)

512 KB Read

37.47 MB/s

43.54 MB/s

38.01 MB/s

- 13.9%

- 1.4%

512 KB Write

38.54 MB/s

66.32 MB/s

56.03 MB/s

- 41.9%

- 31.2%

4 KB Read

0.61 MB/s

0.56 MB/s

0.53 MB/s

+ 8.9%

+ 15.1%

4 KB Write

0.53 MB/s

1.19 MB/s

1.18 MB/s

- 55.5%

- 55.1%

Shockingly, the new 1 TB VelociRaptor did badly in random accesses, compared to its predecessor. It was significantly slower at random writes, and a little less so at large random reads. The good news is its small random reads are slightly faster than the two older VelociRaptors.

This is because of the "Advanced Format Technology effect". The 512-byte emulation mode used saps performance, greatly increasing the latency to perform random accesses, particularly writes. The only reason why the new VelociRaptor managed to eke out a small improvement in small random read speed is because of the higher throughput afforded by the Advanced Technology Format.

 

 

Random Access Time

Test

VelociRaptor
1 TB

VelociRaptor
600 GB

VelociRaptor
300 GB

Difference
(vs. 600 GB)

Difference
(vs. 300 GB)

512 KB Read

13.99 ms

11.48 ms

13.15 ms

+ 21.9%

+ 6.4%

512 KB Write

13.60 ms

7.54 ms

8.93 ms

+ 80.4%

+ 52.3%

4 KB Read

6.75 ms

6.95 ms

7.32 ms

- 2.9%

- 7.8%

4 KB Write

7.73 ms

3.27 ms

3.30 ms

+ 136.4%

+ 134.2%

Although Western Digital never listed the new VelociRaptor's random access time in its specifications, our test revealed why. The new VelociRaptor's random access times were much poorer than its predecessor. Again, a victim of the "Advanced Format Technology effect".

In Western Digital's defence, this cannot be helped as long as they have to use the 512-byte emulation mode. Until that ends, all AFT drives will suffer from the same effect.

 

CPU Utilization (Random Access)

Test

VelociRaptor
1 TB

VelociRaptor
600 GB

VelociRaptor
300 GB

Difference
(vs. 600 GB)

Difference
(vs. 300 GB)

512 KB Read

0.90%

0.29%

0.96%

+ 210.3%

- 6.2%

512 KB Write

0.33%

0.33%

1.77%

-

- 81.3%

4 KB Read

0.29%

0.09%

0.77%

+ 222.2%

- 62.3%

4 KB Write

0.55%

0.23%

1.31%

+ 139.1%

- 58.0%

 

Support Tech ARP!

If you like our work, you can help support out work by visiting our sponsors, participate in the Tech ARP Forums, or even donate to our fund. Any help you can render is greatly appreciated!

Page

Topic

1

Western Digital WD1000DHTZ Overview

2

Introduction, Available Models, Packaging

3

The WD VelociRaptor (WD1000DHTZ)
Usable Capacity, Specification Comparison

4

Connectors & Jumpers, IcePack Frame

5

Testing The WD1000DHTZ
Maximum Surface Temperature
Platter Transfer Rate Profile

6

WinBench 99 Test Results
Transfer Rate Range

7

IO Meter Random Access Performance

8

IO Meter Sequential Access Performance

9

IOPS Scaling (Random Access)

10

IOPS Scaling (Sequential Access)

11

Conclusion, Lowest Prices



 
   
Samsung Galaxy Note5 - Unboxing & First Impressions
The Dell Inspiron 3000 & 5000 Launch Report
Western Digital My Passport Slim (WDBGMT0010BAL) 1 TB Portable Hard Disk Drive Review
The NVIDIA Ninja Graphics Technology Report 2.0
The October '07 Samsung-Tech ARP Bloggers TT Program Rev. 4.0
Creating A WinPE 2.0 Bootable USB Key Rev. 1.1
Zalman ZM600-HP 600W Power Supply Review
L.O.V.E. Affairs
NVIDIA GeForce 7950 GX2 Graphics Card Review Rev. 1.1
SimpleTech PC3700 Nitro Dual-Channel Kit Review

 


Copyright © Tech ARP.com. All rights reserved.