Buy the ARP T-Shirt! BIOS Optimization Guide Money Savers!
 

 02 May 2007
 N/A
  N/A
 Comparisons
 Dr. Adrian Wong
 2.0
 Discuss here !
 654246
 
   
Desktop Graphics Card Comparison Guide Rev. 33.0
Covering 628 desktop graphics cards, this comprehensive comparison allows you ... Read here
BIOS Option Of The Week - Virtualization Technology
Since 1999, we have been developing the BIOS Optimization Guide, affectionately known... Read here
   
Buy The BOG Book Subscribe To The BOG! Latest Money Savers!
Compression Comparison Guide Rev. 2.0
Digg! Reddit!Add to Reddit | Bookmark this article:

Audio Files - WAV (Highly Compressible)

Compression Rate

Data Compressors
Original Size (bytes)
Compressed Size (bytes)
Space Saved (bytes)
SBC Archiver
200,001,146
108,712,099
91,293,075
WinRK
200,001,146
110,171,053
89,834,121
Squeez
200,001,146
112,126,143
87,879,031
WinAce
200,001,146
130,027,582
69,977,592
WinRAR
200,001,146
131,097,819
68,907,355
StuffIt
200,001,146
145,568,533
54,436,641
7-Zip
200,001,146
168,769,308
31,235,866
bzip2
200,001,146
170,512,526
29,492,648
WinZip
200,001,146
178,856,566
21,148,608
gzip
200,001,146
178,953,761
21,051,413
ARJ32
200,001,146
179,144,049
20,861,125

In this test of highly compressible WAV files, we can see the power of the multimedia compression algorithms used in the newer compressors. The relatively unknown trio of SBC Archiver, WinRK and Squeez took the top three places by compressing the fileset to just over 108MB. That translates into an incredible reductions in size of 44-46%.

Current favourites like WinRAR and WinAce did reasonably well in this test, reducing the fileset size by about 35%. Compressors whose algorithms have not been updated for ages, like WinZip, gzip and ARJ32 did poorly. They only managed to reduce the fileset's size by a meager 10.5%.

 

Compression Speed

Data Compressors
Original Size (bytes)
Time (s)
Speed (KB/s)
gzip
200,001,146
15.19
13166.9
ARJ32
200,001,146
21.29
9394.3
WinZip
200,001,146
21.78
9183.0
Squeez
200,001,146
27.93
7160.9
SBC Archiver
200,001,146
44.69
4475.4
WinRAR
200,001,146
45.58
4388.0
bzip2
200,001,146
52.62
3800.9
7-Zip
200,001,146
63.66
3141.8
StuffIt
200,001,146
74.47
2685.7
WinAce
200,001,146
74.98
2667.4
WinRK
200,001,146
119.86
1668.7

When it comes to compression speed, however, things were quite different. The three poorest compressors, WinZip, ARJ32 and gzip were the three fastest compressors. gzip was the fastest by far, achieving a compression speed of over 13MB/s. ARJ32 and WinZip both achieved about 9MB/s, still remarkable compared to the other compressors in the comparison.

Surprisingly, the compression king in the category, SBC Archiver, proved to be reasonably fast at the task, at almost 4.5MB/s. This would certainly make it a very efficient compressor of this fileset. WinRK, which did almost as well as SBC Archiver at compressing these files, was however far slower. In fact, with a maximum compression speed of 1.67MB/s, it was the slowest compressor in this compression.

 

Compression Efficiency

The compression efficiency rating is a simple way to evaluate the efficiency of each data compressor. This way, we can see which compressor can save the most space in the least time.

Please note that a higher efficiency rating does not mean the compressor is better. It just means the compressor has a better compression-to-speed ratio. A more efficient compressor is, of course, always more desirable than a less efficient one.

The most efficient data compressors when it came to WAV files was Squeez. Its tremendous compression rate, third only to SBC Archiver and WinRK, combined with its fast compression speed allowed Squeez to become the undisputed efficiency champion. It was over 50% as efficient as its nearest competitor, SBC Archiver.

The WAV compression king, SBC Archiver, only managed a rather distant second place because it was much slower than Squeez while attaining only a slightly higher compression rate. However, it was four times more efficient than 7-Zip, which had the dubious honour of being the most efficient compressor of WAV files. 7-Zip's mediocre compression rate of 15.6%, coupled with its mediocre compression speed of 3.1MB/s made it the most inefficient compressor of the bunch.



<<< Fast: Conclusion : Previous Page   |   Next Page : Normal: Audio Files - MP3 (Poorly Compressible) >>>

 

 
   
Sony α7R II, Cyber-shot RX10 II & Cyber-shot RX100 IV Launch
#IncredibleZenDay - The Launch Of The ASUS ZenFone 2
Western Digital My Passport Ultra Metal / Anniversary Edition 2 TB Portable Hard Disk Drive Review
Kingston DataTraveler Ultimate 3.0 Flash Drive (USB 3.0) Review
Western Digital 320 GB Scorpio Notebook Hard Drive Review
Compression Comparison Guide Rev. 2.0
NVIDIA GeForce 7600 GT Tech Report
OCZ EL PC-3200 Gold DDR Memory Overview
Video BIOS Flashing Guide
Warcraft III : Frozen Throne

 


Copyright © Tech ARP.com. All rights reserved.